Tube

TUBE

and

THE GOLDEN RULE OF SPECIAL RELATIVITY

Han Erim

April 14, 2010

Hello Everybody

Until so far, I have patiently waited of my readers to reach the mental maturity. Anymore, I observe that I have readers who are willing to read my articles and understand what I have put in them. Because of the fact that you have reached that level, I want to present my gratitude to all of you.

This article is really successful because Special Relativity will be quite clear in there as you will see. My article takes its name from an apparatus which is called “tube”.

First of all, I will introduce this apparatus which we will use in there. This is a tube which its air is vacuumed and which has light sources on both of each side. Inside the tube, there are two slides which move on the track. On the slides, there are two sensors both of which have equal distance to the centre, and the third sensor exists in the middle of the slides. These sensors are sensitive to the light and they are useful to identify the access moment of the light to the edge of the slides and to the middle of it. The slides can measure the speed of light which reaches them. By using the control panel, the speed of the slides can be arranged to a value between 0 and c (speed of light). The lamps on both sides of the tube can be switched on with a button whenever you want. The control of the device can completely be done externally and you will be able to control it here. The figure on the below shows the device and its parts. Please, examine it. (Figure 1)

We can strengthen our knowledge about the device. The device is designed suitable for the symmetry principle. That is;

Both lights are always triggered at the same time.
The speeds of the slides are always equal but they are on the opposite direction.
The distances of the slides to the symmetry axis are always equal.

The triggering time of lights is arranged with the small brown triangle buttons which can be slid to the left and right. The light is triggered as soon as the yellow triangle button below the slide touch as with this button.

As the device is designed suitable for symmetry principle, we can say this one easily: The actions which occurred on the left side of symmetry axis occur exactly on the right side of symmetry axis. For example, when the light moving from the left side reaches the slide, the light moving from the right side will reach the other slide at the same time. There is no need for any hesitations about this subject.

Our aim is to enable the lights coming from both sides to reach the sensor simultaneously, which is in the middle of the slide, when the slides are moving. If we turn on the lights late or early when the slides are moving, it is sure that the lights will not reach the middle sensor at the same time. This situation occurs correctly when the lights turn on the right time. Thus, since we can control the speed of the slides and in which time we will turn on the light, there certainly exists a situation in which both lights could reach in the middle of the sensors.

We can set up the above paragraph as a rule.

GOLDEN RULE: Let's think it with a single slide, since we can control the speed of the slide and the time when we turn on the lights, there is a certain situation in which both lights could reach the middle sensor of the slide at the same time. What’s more, since the device has worked according to the symmetry principle, the lights will reach to the middle sensors of both slides at the same time.

I do not think that you can disagree with the golden rule because it is obvious that the situation which the Golden Rule occurs certainly exists. This rule is really important because of the fact that we can answer the question of “What is Special Relativity?" when we find the condition which enables the Golden Rule. By using the device below, try to enable the Golden Rule. (Figure 2)

If you think that the answer is simple, I may say that you are wrong. You may claim that there is only one situation which enables the golden rule and it should be like that: when the middle points of the slides reach on the symmetry axis, the lights should reach the symmetry axis. You think that golden rule is carried out on this condition. Even if this kind of inferences seems to be right, it is definitely wrong.

It is wrong because the sensors on both sides of the slides show us that this logical inference is wrong. Let’s think by paying attention to only one slide. In physics, we certainly know that if we had put a lamp in the middle of the slides and had turned on them, the lights would have reached the sensors on both sides at the same time. Whether the slides are moving or stay still does not make any change. We can think the contrary, as well. If we had put lamps on each sensor which is located on both sides and had turned them on at the same time, the lights would have reached to the middle sensor at the same moment. It does not again change the situations whether the slides are moving or not. Then, there is a compulsory result like that: the lights firstly need to reach the sensors on each side at the same time in order to reach the sensor in the middle at the same time. Only when this condition is provided, the lights will reach the middle sensor at the same time. (Figure 3)

Now, you see that suddenly every thing has become abruptly. Because if we question the reason we had, we can see easily that the lights cannot reach the sensors on the edges at the same time. We are face to face with a real paradox. Let's explicate the paradox in three parts.

Think that the moment when the middle points of slides reach the symmetry axis, the lights have reach the sensors on the edges. In this case, the lights will not reach to the middle sensors at the same time. This is the part one. (Figure 4-A)

If the lights and the middle sensors meet on the symmetry axis, the lights could not reach to sensors on the edges at the same time on this condition. This is the part two. (Figure 4-B)

Any solution which violates the symmetry principle will not be valid. The lights should reach the sensors on the edges of both slides at the same time and then they should reach the sensor in the middle at the same time. This is the part three.

We cannot claim that any solution which enables the golden rule is impossible because it is a clear fact that there has to be a solution. You send the lights from both sides and they could not reach the middle sensor simultaneously under no circumstances. It will be rather ridiculous to suggest such a thesis. Also, it will be a nonsense thesis to suggest that the lights would reach the sensor in the middle at the same time without reaching the sensors on the edges of slides at the same time. This thesis violates all of our physic knowledge. Another issue which makes our task difficult is the symmetry principle. For a solution, we cannot offer a situation in which all conditions are provided only for a single slide by violating the symmetry principle.

As you see, we are trapped by the boundaries of the device. It does not allow any solution contrary to its design and its principles. Besides these, the truth physic law which belongs to the nature what ever it is represented by a condition which enables the Golden Rule. We have to find it.

Now, it is time to say something to the people occupied with the work of physics. You can think that you may find a solution providing Golden Rule without violating the principles mentioned here and by paying attention to the Special Relativity and making use of present knowledge about the subject. However, you will see that the device will certainly not let such a kind of solution. In the solution which you have proposed, the lights should reach the edges of both slides at the same time; they then should reach the middle point at the same time and the symmetry principle certainly should not be violated while these are happening. In addition to these, you should be able to show everything step by step about the way in which you propose as a solution. You should write the situation of both lights and the slides in any moment of t. I am saying clearly that you cannot solve this paradox with your current knowledge because the mathematics of Special Relativity suggested by Albert Einstein is unable to solve this paradox. You will be left on the middle of the road by your physic education and your present knowledge. In this process, if I were you, I would start to study and try to find the solution which enables the Golden Rule instead of challenging these arguments.

It is a fact that if we wish to reach the Golden Rule, we should accept that there are some missing points in our current physics knowledge which I mean the missing points in the theory of Special Relativity. In this position, the solution cannot be found in the mathematics of Albert Einstein. By using some concepts such as space contraction, time dilation which are based on Einstein’s mathematics, you fail to solve this paradox. It means that if you want find the Golden Rule, you should go on your way alone after this step.

Alice Law and Golden Rule

I have been studying on Alice Law for years and I have experienced the difficulties step by step which you may face with right now. In here, I will tell you how Alice Law enables the Golden Rule. When I tell it, I will have told you what Special Relativity brings out and what its real mathematics is.

We have to focus on the lights getting out of the device in order to reach the solution. As we know, the light consists of photons and there are numerous photons within a ray of light. Therefore, there will be numerous photons in the ray of light which goes to the slides. At this point, let's think not with the ray of light’s itself but the photons located within the ray of light and make a suggestion like that: each photon should go with the constant c speed according to its arrival target. It is sure that such kind of suggestion will be out of current physic knowledge but it does not matter. Because since the time when we understand that the physic of Einstein is unable to solve this matter, the threshold which limits us has been spontaneously crossed. The important thing is to find the way of the solution which enables the golden rule.

In such a kind of solution, since "every photon goes with c constant speed according to their arrival target", the ray of light which is together in the beginning should be decomposed gradually. In this example, the ray of light will be decomposed into two since there are two different available slides which go different directions from the arrival target of photons. (Figure 5)

A new proposal as “every photon goes with c constant speed according to their arrival target” is enough to reach the solution. Therefore, the Golden Rule is enabled without violating any principle. The act of the lights will be as below. Every photon will move with c speed according to its target slide. You can enable the Golden Rule on the below by using the device. In there, the lights (photons) act as told in the Alice Law. (Figure 6)

I have told that any principle whose boundaries are drawn on the above are not violated in the solution proposed by Alice Law. The solution shows us when the lights should be turned on without any hesitation. If you want to enable the Golden Rule, there is only one position for the moment of turning on the lights: the lights should be turned on in the moment when the middle points of slides reach the symmetry axis. In this situation, all necessary conditions are enabled. The lights firstly reach the sensors on the edges of the slides at the same time and then they reach the sensors on the middle points at the same time. Also, the symmetry principle is preserved with this way. We should be careful that the slides measure the speed of light as c under any circumstances whatever their speed are.

It is an important point that the existence of a solution which enables the Golden Rule proves the existence of Alice Law mathematically. After this point it is very easy, this behavior of the lights (photons) will be the reason of Special Relativity and this kind of act commands us that the new mathematics of Special Relativity will be like (c+v) (c-v) mathematics.

In Alice Law, a slight difference has been done in the theory of Albert Einstein to enable the Golden Rule. The results of this slight difference are magnificent. First of all, the Special Relativity theory turns into a LAW instead of remaining as a theory. Moreover, Alice Law and Special Relativity theory becomes more comprehensible and its mathematics become simple. I can tell you (c+v) (c-v) mathematics as in the following sentences. If we call the speed of slide as “v”, according to us staying control panel the speed of lights going towards the slides (according to the moving direction of slides and by depending on the direction of lights) will be (c+v) (c-v). According to slides, the speed of the lights which comes towards itself are always c; it means they are constant. There is a sensitive and delicate relation between c light constant and (c+v) (c-v) mathematics.

Dear readers, I have largely completed what I should write about the Special Relativity part of Alice Law. You can access to my entire current article from my main page. Since these articles show the real rules of the nature and consist of the results of (c+v) (c-v) mathematics, please pay attention to them and encourage other people to read them.

On the forthcoming days, I will publish two more articles about the Special Relativity. Firstly, I will publish a manifesto and I will invite all physicists to gather under the flag of Alice Law with this manifesto. Secondly, I will publish an article whose topic will be the relation between GPS (Global Positioning System) and Special Relativity. Best regards to all.

Han Erim

aliceinphysics.com

Establish: December 2001